文档介绍：/~tw/phdOutlineWhatisareview?Whyshouldyoureview?Howdoyoureviewapaper?Whatnottodo?Whatarethedilemmas?CasestudyWhatisareview?“Somethingthatwillruinyourday”AlanBundyEvenifitisgood!ThestampofscientificqualityFeedbackfromyourpeersFuturedirections??Acceptance/rejectionEditors/ept/mend!Aplaceforbias,prejudice,personalanimosity,…ThoughitoftenappearstobesoWhyshouldyoureview?You’dmuchratherenjoyPaphosAndsowouldI!ButsciencewouldgrindtoahaltNotimmediately,ofcourseReasonstoreviewDutyFairness2-3reviewswritten/paperwrittenPromotionEducationGoodreviewerswritegoodpapers?BadreasonstoreviewTosettleoldscoresToadvanceyourowntheories/hinderrivalsTogetlatestresultsUnpublishedpapersarestrictlyconfidentialHowdoyoureview?ReadthepaperReadthereviewformUsefuldimensionstolookatNovelty,Clarity,Importance,Timeliness…ReadthepaperWaitafewdaysReadpaperWritereviewEveryonehastheirownmethodHowdoyoureview?Putyourselfinauthor’sshoesThinkhowyouwouldliketoreadthisreviewOfferconstructivecriticismDon’tjusttellthemsomethingisinadequate!TellthemhowtheymightfixitWhatnottodo?MissthedeadlineWeallhatelatereviewsDisplaypartiality,bias,animosity,…DestructivelycriticizeAlwaysworkoutwhattheywouldneedtodotofixproblems