刑事鉴定意见的法庭质证研究.pdf

文档介绍：上海交通大学硕士学位论文学位论文原创性声明 I 万方数据上海交通大学硕士学位论文摘要 II 万方数据上海交通大学硕士学位论文摘要 III 刑事鉴定意见的法庭质证研究摘要刑事鉴定意见作为一种重要的证据形式在诉讼中越发关键。立法规定了鉴定意见必须经过法庭质证环节,经过法庭调查查证属实后才能作为定案的根据,而法官面对涉及专门问题的鉴定意见束手无策, 质证流于形式,只能鉴定意见的形式角度予以判断,受制于专业的限制而过分依赖鉴定意见。本文通过考察国外对于鉴定意见(专家证言)可采性相关规则, 分析我国刑事鉴定意见质证现状,从质证内容和质证程序两大部分试图确立一套适合我国鉴定体制的裁判规则。质证内容上,根据我国证据三性的判断框架,针对鉴定意见的特殊性,细化地明确了刑事鉴定意见的非法排除规则、可靠性规则和必要性规则。质证程序上,完善了交叉询问规则和强化提出了辩护律师的质证主体作用及相关规则。另外,细化了鉴定人出庭、鉴定意见庭前开示、专家辅助人和鉴定人责任等配套保障制度。为法官及控辩双方对鉴定意见的充分有效质证提供一套全面的指引规则。关键词刑事鉴定,质证万方数据上海交通大学硕士学位论文 ABSTRACT IV THE RESEARCH ON THE EXAMINATIONPROCEDURE OF THE CRIMINALEXPERTOPINION ABSTRACT The evidence is the core issue of the litigation, all litigation activities around the collection and utilization of evidenceare critical. as an important form of evidence, the criminal expert opinionin which expert conclusion isplaying an increasingly significant to the legislation,expert opinion must be verified before as the basis for judge’s decision inthe court, but inthe criminal litigation practicein our country, the judge is so helpless while facinghow to judge the expert opinion. In this paper, through studythe admissibility of expert testimony rules, analysis of the criminal expert opinion to cross-examine the status quo, from the content of cross-examination and cross-examination procedures of two major rules of adjudication trying to establish a suitable identification system in our country. In addition, the refinement of the identified person to appear expert opinion, pretrial discovery, 万方数据上海交通大学硕士学位论文 ABSTRACT V experts and experts or liability supporting security systemprovide a comprehensive set of guidelines rules for both the judges and the prosecution and the defense on the full and effective cross-examination of expert opinion.. KEYWORDScriminal expert opinion,examination procedure 万方数据上海交通大学硕士学位论文目录 VI 目录引言..............................................................